
"Dr. Octogon had no answers!"
Three out the four wild card game matchups this coming weekend are rematches from last week. Let that sink in for a minute. Because unlike every MSM writer I’ve read this week, this is actually the purpose of this post, not just a quirky footnote. I can just imagine the Fox Sunday crew trying to talk about the anomaly that this is:

Curt: Guys, how do you feel about the insane improbability that has occurred this week, with three of the four wild-card games being rematches of week 17 matchups?
Terry: WHOOO YEAHH!! OOOH DOGGY! GIMME SOME OF THAT!!
Howie: Radio Shack.Chevy trucks.Radio Shack.Chevy trucks.vrooom go fast.
Strahan: I have a sitcom!
Jimmy: Well Curt, one time in 1993 Charles Haley mushroom-stamped the same rookie receiver in the locker room TWO STRAIGHT WEEKS IN A ROW!
Anyway, I think the blandness of these three games last week is what has led the MSM to kind of disregard exploring this oddity. The Bengals, with nothing to really gain by playing hard, played a “vanilla” game and kept their playbook closed while getting smoked by the Jets. Once the Vikings won in the early game, the Cards also had nothing left to gain so they called Matt Leinart away from whatever frat party he was at to play QB vs. the Pack, and the Cards got smoked as well. The Eagles/Cowboys game was actually quite entertaining, as they were playing for the division crown still, and thus playing for a wild card home game.
The sheer improbability of this happening is what truly blows my mind. Lets say you are an NFL team, the Jets maybe (because the name is short and I’m lazy). There’s 31 other teams in the league, so obviously you’ll play 1/31 in week 17. Then there is the fact that you are a playoff team also, which only 12/32 are each year (37.5%). Then there’s the fact that this same scenario is also applicable to the other team as well, in this case the Bengals. This happened to SIX teams this year, or again, three games.

The odds of this happening the way it did this year is ~eleventy billion to 1. I may have to check my math though.
Since 1990 (when the playoff format changed to it’s current system), a wild-card game featuring a week 17 rematch has happened 9 times TOTAL. So once every two years. To have three happen in the same season is quite crazy.
Now the NFL scheduling does try to encourage storylines like this to happen. They fail the majority of the time, though, because of the tremendous amount of parity in the league, the season by season fluctuation of playoff teams that is unrivaled by the other professional leagues. Here’s last season’s playoff teams, with teams in bold being teams who have returned to the playoffs this year:
2008: NY Giants, Carolina, Minnesota, Arizona, Atlanta, Philadelphia, Tennessee, Pittsburgh, Indianapolis, San Diego, Miami, Baltimore.
Half are repeat playoff teams, a number thats actually quite the par for the NFL. Now look back to last Sunday again and the matchups. Minnesota/NY Giants, Pittsburgh/Miami…there’s a couple out-of-division matchups the league saved for week 17 in hopes of creating drama. Of course neither of those did matter, but yet three others did.






